Arrogant Americans, Mr. President?

[kshillbillys]

Arrogant Americans, Mr. President?
Peter Heck - Guest Columnist -
4/14/2009 7:50:00 AM

As I was sitting in church waiting for the start of the service, my grandpa came walking towards me pointing his finger. No matter how old I get, and no matter how long he's been out of the U.S. Navy, that's still an intimidating sight. As he approached me, his voice quivered as he said, "We saved that continent twice...how dare my president apologize for this country's arrogance." My grandpa is right. Americans need not apologize to the world for their arrogance; rather, Americans should apologize to their forefathers for the arrogance of their president.

Barack Obama's first foreign trip as President of the United States has confirmed the naiveté so many of us feared during t he election cycle. But worse than that, it has also demonstrated that our president suffers from either a complete misunderstanding of our heritage and history, or an utter contempt for it.  Neither is excusable.


Garnering cheers from the French of all people, President Obama declared, "In America, there is a failure to appreciate Europe's leading role in the world.  Instead of celebrating your dynamic union and seeking to partner with you to meet common challenges, there have been times where America has shown arrogance and been dismissive, even derisive." Consider that Obama spoke these words just 500 miles from the beaches of Normandy, where the sand is still stained with 65-year-old blood of "arrogant Americans."

Indeed, columnist Mark Whittington observes, "One should remind Mr. Obama and the Europeans how America has 'shown arrogance' by saving Europe from itself innumerable times in the 20th Century. World War I, World War II, the Cold War, and the wars in the Balkans were largely resolved by American blood, treasure, and leadership." But all that appears lost on the president's seemingly insatiable quest to mend fences he imagines have been tarnished by the bullish George W. Bush.


If Obama wishes to continue trampling the presidential tradition of showing class to former office holders and publicl y trash Bush for his own personal gain, so be it. But all Americans should make clear that no man - even if he is the president - will tarnish the legacy of those Americans who have gone before us. Ours is not a history of arrogance. It is a history of courage, self-sacrifice, and honor.

When abusive monarchs repressed the masses, Americans resisted and overthrew them. When misguided policies led to the unjust oppression of fellow citizens, Americans rebelled and overturned them. When millions of impoverished and destitute wretches sought a new beginning, Americans threw open the door and welcomed them. When imperial dictators were on the march, Americans surrendered their lives to stop them. When communist thugs threatened world peace, Americans bled to defeat them. When an entire continent was overwhelmed with famine and hunger, Americans gave of themselves to sustain it. When terrorist madmen killed the innocent and subjugated
millions, Americans led the fight to topple them.

This is the legacy that generations of Americans have left. If President Obama seeks stronger relations with the world community, perhaps he should begin by reminding them of these very truths, rather than condemning his own countrymen on foreign shores.

This "obsessive need to put down his own country," has caused blog ger James Lewis to call President Obama a "stunningly ignorant man" who has evidently never spoken to a concentration camp survivor, a Cuban refugee, a boat person from Vietnam, a Soviet dissident, or a survivor of Mao's purges.

Unfortunately, I can no longer bring myself to give Mr. Obama that benefit of the doubt. Not after looking at the pain in my grandpa's eyes...a man who still carries shrapnel in his body from his service to this country.

As a student and teacher of history, I recognize that America has made mistakes...plenty of them, in fact. But one of the great things about our people has been their courage and humility in admitting and correcting those mistakes. God willing, they will prove that willingness again in four years and correct the mistake that is the presidency of Barack Obama.

[Diane Amberg]

So only Repubs. spilled blood willingly for their country? 

[kshillbillys]

Silly me, but I didn't catch the word REPUBLICAN in that column...

[Wilma]

And why do you think that the rest of the world thinks that Americans are arrogant?

[Diane Amberg]

Ok, then, how about "conservative" or Pro Obama or something that portrays only a few loyal patriots. Every possible kind of person shed blood over there. Did you ever hear the phrase "Ugly American"? I've sure seen a few when I've been oversees. ( Frankly, the worst were the German tourists... loud and very pushy.) It's politics! In no way do I think he, or Pres. Bush or any other President  would be out to embarrass us intentionally. He and Pres. Bush have totally different personalities. Should we isolate ourselves from the world and peer out at everyone through gun slits? Or should we try to be part of the  open world? Confidence and arrogance are two different things. We are and should always be a straight, tall, shoulders back, and confident people. Arrogance is an ugly word.

[kshillbillys]

I don't think America is arrogant at all. I think we are a wonderful country who are always at the ready to go and HELP others. Mr. O is the one who said we were arrogant. He's the one making excuses.

[Diane Amberg]

I stand by my statement. Some Americans are indeed very arrogant. I don't think arrogance is a good word no matter who uses it including any American President. It's politics!

[kshillbillys]

1 : exaggerating or disposed to exaggerate one's own worth or importance often by an overbearing manner <an arrogant official>
2 : proceeding from or characterized by arrogance <an arrogant reply>
synonyms see proud

I am very PROUD to be an American....guess that makes me arrogant too!

[dnalexander]

This thread causes my thoughts to swirl and I am not sure anyone else is willing to debate this for the time necessary to do it justice. Most of the threads here die without the full in depth discussion. I am not pointing fingers, I am guilty too.

Arrogant Americans goes to a major issue of how to handle foreign policy. It doesn't matter if we are or not that is how we are perceived by much of the rest of the world. Much of managing a situation is not managing reality it is managing everyone's perceptions

The world sees us as arrogant. We need to deal with that. If we have to admit our mistakes and maybe show a conciliatory respect, I am all for it if it helps further our standing and perception in the world.

David

[Wilma]

That is what I have heard and read about how the rest of the world sees Americans.  I think maybe they have a good reason to think that.  After watching some of our TV shows that the rest of the world is also seeing, that is the image that they could be picking up.  I think some Americans are arrogant in the way they interact with other countries.  Unfortunately these are the ones that are remembered.

If apologizing for the arrogance of some Americans establishes a better relationship, then let it be.