Hero of Battle of Stoney Creek - War of 1812

[Sir Charles deMouton-Black]

    
The hero of Stoney Creek

As Canada prepares to mark the bicentennial of the War of 1812, an Ontario historian is urging long-overdue recognition of a 'virtually unknown' hero whose stunning exploits during the 'pivotal' Battle of Stoney Creek, he says, should rank Sgt. Alexander Fraser alongside Isaac Brock and Laura Secord as a saviour of the nation.
Photograph by: James Elliott, Photo Handout

Read more: http://www.timescolonist.com/news/Forgotten+hero+saved+Canada+1813+Historian/3113923/story.html?id=3113923#ixzz0q7DYp4Jy

As Canada prepares to mark the bicentennial of the War of 1812, a historian is urging long-overdue recognition for a "virtually unknown" hero whose stunning exploits during the "pivotal" Battle of Stoney Creek, he says, should rank Sgt. Alexander Fraser alongside Isaac Brock and Laura Secord as a saviour of the nation.

James Elliott, an author and journalist from Hamilton, recently published the most comprehensive account so far of the June 1813 battle on the Niagara Peninsula that unexpectedly thwarted the American army's advance through Upper Canada.

And the crucial moment in Canada's successful defence, he argues, was a daring charge through the darkness on June 6 — 197 years ago this Sunday — by the bayonet-wielding Fraser.

The Scottish-born sergeant, just 23 at the time, would be credited with spearing seven enemy soldiers, seizing control of a key American artillery position and — most remarkably — capturing two U.S. generals, all in a matter of minutes.

Fraser's incredible charge essentially "decapitated" the invasion force, Elliott says, robbing U.S. troops of both Gen. John Chandler — who "never escaped the stigma of Stoney Creek, and bore it like a curse until he died" — and Gen. William Winder.

Elliott is the historian most adamant about Fraser's underrated role in the outcome of the War of 1812, but he isn't the only one to draw attention to his heroics.

The late Pierre Berton, in his Flames Across the Border account of the war, described the "crazy abandon" of the Fraser-led charge and expressed amazement at how the badly outnumbered British-Canadian forces at Stoney Creek repulsed the American advance.

"As the result of a single unequal contest, hastily planned at the last minute and fought in absolute darkness by confused and disorganized men," Berton wrote, "the invaders have lost control."

Fraser's younger brother, Peter, killed four Americans in the assault. And the man directing the charge, Maj. Charles Plenderleath, is well known to have been courageous in command, taking two musket balls in the thigh and earning the Order of the Bath for his own exertions.

Elliott says it was Alexander Fraser's battlefield leadership, though, that saved the day — and perhaps the country.

"It is by no means a stretch to connect Fraser's charge and the subsequent collapse of the Niagara campaign of 1813," says Elliott, author of Strange Fatality: The Battle of Stoney Creek, 1813.

The halting of the U.S. push into the future Ontario, Elliott contends, hinged on Fraser's nighttime ambush of the enemy gunners, who were threatening to extend earlier U.S. victories and drive British-Canadian forces into a wholesale retreat from the Niagara frontier.

"I don't think it's generally appreciated how pivotal an action Stoney Creek was and how close the Americans came to bagging not only Upper Canada but possibly Lower Canada as well," he told Canwest News Service.

"Had the Victoria Cross existed, Fraser would have been a prime candidate."

Fraser was given a promotion after the battle, and following the war he remained in Canada and settled with other Scottish immigrants in the Ottawa Valley town of Perth, Ont.

He later saw action helping to put down the Upper Canada Rebellion in 1837 and raised a large family before his death at age 82 in 1872.

He was eulogized in the local newspaper as "the beau ideal of a Highland gentleman" and as "a soldier every inch."

Fraser was buried in the town's Old Pioneer Cemetery, notes Elliot, "his pivotal role in the Battle of Stoney Creek virtually unknown in the country he helped save."
© Copyright (c) Canwest News Service

[Dr. Bob]

Sir Charles,

Leaders on both sides brought the war to a virtual draw, with neither side gaining any territory and both limited glory!  It is a interesting story with little to make either side very proud.  I re-enact on both sides of the War.  Us Engineer and Surgeon of the 95th Reg't. of Foot - Rifles.  The treaty of Ghent was signed in Dec. of 1814, but several battles were fought in 1815 because the news crossed the Atlantic very slowly.  New Orleans being the best known of them!  The War certainly gave a sense of national identity to both sides!