A few Questions about CAS

[Sundown Storm]

Greetings,
I have a few questions, if I may be so bold as to probably re-ask some that have most likely been asked previously:

1) is the New Ruger Vaquero appropriate and accurate as a CAS gun 'out-of-the-box'?
1a) is the New Ruger Vaquero reasonably period correct?
2) Can black powder loads be shot through them with no serious problems?
3) Is an open-top revolver (like the Cimmaron) appropriate for carrying concealed in the 'real world'?
4) do those same open-top revolvers neccessitate black powder loads, or reduced loads with smokeless?


okay, thanks, that's all that I have for now.

I appreciate it

[Sagebrush Burns]

1 - Yes, they're just fine.
2 - Close enough.
3 - Don't know, I only shoot smokeless.
4 - There are many better choices.
5 - They are not as strong as solid frame revolvers.

[Four-Eyed Buck]

1. Yes, it is. Especially if you're new to shooting or at least single actions.
1A. Yes, the new ones are almost the same size as the Colt SAA, and from a distance is almost undistinguishable from it( I have one in .45Colt,5 1/2")
2. Guys are using BP in them, but some have reported problems because of the barrel gap being tight.
3. Lengthwise maybe not a good choice for concealed. Also better for BP or light smokeless, not heavy self defense loads.
                                              Buck

[Sundown Storm]

I appreciate the responses, Gentlemen. I appreciate your assistance and your candor.