This may be a little old of a thread but I'd like to stir this pot up a bit, from a newcomer's perspective.
see, my pirate re-enactment group has two basic "factions" the hard-core perfect pirate that you'd never want to take home with you until they become civilian again, and then those that have fun with it, and think it's a fun Halloween party once a month!
I kind of feel that SASS vs NCOWS is similar to those two "factions" one likes to dress the part and fire the guns...
the other it seems likes to "live" the part, all of it. The blackpowder, the colt peacemakers in .45 only and having 250 shot and having everything look perfect.
Basically if a person came into the range at a SASS event they'd see people playing cowboy and having a blast with their period guns.
If a person came into the range at a NCOWS event, they'd feel like they stepped back in time.
now this is just my personal opinion, and I would like to be a member of both, with the same outfit, just that there is a SASS Posse 8 miles away from me (the range!) and I'm trying to find a NCOWS group somewhat close, maybe two hours away, max.
now for the SASS group, awesome I get to get away for a day and enjoy some comraderie with like-minded people for a day.
for the NCOWS group, same thing, except I actually get to experience what it was like back then, all the way down to the mannerisms and shot used.
now again, this is just from a complete wanna-be noob and anthropology/history major! but that is my new-comer's perspective... and I'd like to join both. After all, one primary reason I picked USFA for my peacemaker is because she's so accurate to the real deal, it's in .45 caliber and so will my Marlin rifle. They are American made and as accurate as I can get to what they were like back then, right down to the markings.
Did I choose those brands because of NCOWS? no. I'd like to join NCOWS because I already wanted to be that accurate and it's a small under-the-radar group, like an underground awesome blues band. I had no clue what NCOWS was until these forums, before that it was SASS only, but hey, thanks to CASCity, I'm here aren't I?