I agree with the "Dragoon." Too much Barrel/Cylinder gap. I'm going to guess your still getting some excess contact between the hammer and the frame and or back of the Arbor. Need to look for that.
The Slix nipples are also a very good investment in your case. Some will argue with me, but when I set up a Cap Gun, I prefer contact between the hammer face and the nipple. The Slix nipple is a tad longer than a stock Pietta and may just fix your short hammer issue.
The Slix will give you better ignition in any case and are worth the investment.
Coffinmaker