Please, Your Opinion is Needed Here

[Two Flints]

Hello SSS,

Appearing below are two Civil War Insignias attributed to General James H. Wilson's Cavalry Corps.  One of these insignias is currently on sale on Ebay - described as an accurate reproduction of the Wilson cavalry corps insignia.  The other insignia is on display at Arlington National Cemetary and is described as a "Very rare "Wilson's Cavalry" gold badge, named to General Wirt Davis" who served as an officer during the Civil War and the Indian Wars.

INSIGNIA #1


INSIGNIA #2


My question to you, do you see a difference in the insignias?  Are they both Sharps?  Are they both Spencers? or which one is a Sharps and which one is a Spencer?  Can you see a difference in the two carbines?  Let me know, please.

Two Flints

[major]

TF
# 1 looks to be a Spencer and # 2 is definitely a Sharps.
Terry

[Major 2]

# 1 is  blurry ...could be a Spencer  ...also looks a tad 4th model Burnside-ish ( a bit fat though  )
#2 is a Sharps
the cross Sabers are different as well ( different shape Basket guards )

[Advertising]

[Henry4440]

TF,

#2 no question it is a Sharps.

#1 i think it's a Spencer.Take a closer look at the 'nose'.



 

[Forty Rod]

#2 rifle is noticeably shorter than #1.

[Sagebrush Burns]

Looks to me like #2 is a Sharps for sure and #1 is maybe a Spencer.

[minerotago]

No 1 - looks like a Spencer and although I tihnk it is one I would not bet on it.

No2 - Now I would be quite happy to bet on it being a Sharps and I'm not the betting sort unless I know for sure that I am going to win!

[PvtGreg]

#1 - is a Star
#2 - is a Smith
#3 - A Palmer (I think)
#4 - is a Burnsides
#5 - is of course a Spencer
#6 - No Clue
#7 - is either a Merrill or a Jenks (I think)